Iran admits to unintentionally shooting down Ukrainian plane

This AM I woke up to dozens of messages from family/friends in Iran Right now, Iran is a tinderbox internally. As some of you know, there are protests mostly around the anger that Iranians feel towards the gov after they admitted IRGC shot down the Ukraine Airlines aircraft,

Iranians who are protesting and all the family/friends I spoke to (who live in different parts of Iran) are furious that they were lied to for three days about the cause of the plane crash. The Iranian government lied left and right about where the plane was headed

What brought down the plane. The Iranian government completely mishandled the plane crash, destroying evidence in the process. Iranians are in the street calling for death to the Supreme Leader (something that could get them executed).

Iranians are in the street calling for prosecutions, saying Soleimani is a murderer. Telling leadership of the Iranian government to resign and saying that Trump isn’t the problem, that the Iranian government is. To say that these protesters are brave is an understatement

Nearly 2 months ago, Iran massacred hundreds (at least) and up to 1,500 of its citizens in the streets for protesting against gas prices. People in the streets are taking an enormous risk not only by protesting but by saying what they’re saying like death to the Supreme Leader

I’m told that there will be expanded protests Sunday night in Iran (these things are always subject to change, particularly with intimidation from the government). So the question is what kind of support are the Iranian people going to get from the external world?

Yesterday I tweeted this thread and was criticized by liberals who are intent on blaming this plane crash on President Trump. As I note in my thread, the idea that he’s to blame for a decision the IRGC made is just absurd.

The idea that the US is to blame for the Iranian military shooting down a civilian plane in its own airspace is patently absurd. Mistakes happen…but the fog of war is not to blame here. And the Iranians need to take responsibility for not shutting down civilian air traffic

And while Iranians aren’t a monolith and there are 80 million people in Iran, you don’t see Iranians blaming President Trump for the cash (in which Iranian citizens were killed). They’re blaming the IRGC and the Supreme Leader for a series of horrific mistakes

I’ve gone through some of the most active and prominent liberal Twitter accounts and none of them mentioned the Iran protests today. These same people were actively tweeting about wanting to avoid war and attacking Trump for his decision. What happened?

And that’s why I tweeted this earlier today. In this context, Iranians are being used by certain people on the left (i didn’t say all) as a tool to attack President Trump. But these same people don’t seem to care to to support their right to protest?

Right now the right and left are both using Iran and Iranians for their domestic political purposes and it’s quite disgusting.

It seems to me the protests were inconvenient for some of these folks today. They were placing the blame on the Iranian leadership who lied repeatedly about what happened. They weren’t blaming President Trump…so it wasn’t worth it to bring attention to or support them?

This happens often with people living in authoritarian states & with certain religious/ethnic groups. We’re used as tools to push domestic political agendas. We’re told what to feel & think by people with no connection to our country & have no idea what they’re talking about


Yashar Ali 🐘


Updated: January 12, 2020 — 4:43 am
avatar
7 Comment threads
0 Thread replies
0 Followers
 
Most reacted comment
Hottest comment thread
7 Comment authors
AnonymousAnonymousAnonymousAnonymousAnonymous Recent comment authors
newest oldest most voted
Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous

The Iranian govt lied abt the cause of the plane’s destruction. It was bungled in the worst poss. way, & 100s of innocent lives were lost.
At the same time, an incompetent man, holding office through int’l treachery, ordered a drone strike assassination that precipitated…

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous

Trump isn’t directly to blame, but he stirred up the hornets nest that led to this. It’s a scary time. I don’t like any country who’s leadership is eager to suppress ppl & demand for war. Most citizens would rather live in peace, others manipulated to think war is best. ☮

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous

I’d like to say…I totally agree…except I truly believe that Trump started this whole mess due to impeachment.
Do I blame Iran…hell yes.
Do I think, if Trump wasnt impeached he would have not started this…hell yes
Blessings on yr friends & family.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous

If we had a POTUS who was able to effectively communicate with our allies, we could present a unified front to pressure the Supreme Leader to step down. Sadly, we have chosen to go it alone and will be ineffective in any messaging. I fear more bloodshed in Iranian streets.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous

Liberals can be maddingly inconsistent. I applaud the courage of the Iranian protesters…it’s hard to get Americans to protest when there’s zero penalty.

Also, these two things are true.
1) If Trump wasn’t
@POTUS
those people are alive.
2) IRGC shot down the plane.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous

It’s a shame Trump has made himself so unlikable that this thread needed to be written. It’s true what you say. But it’s impossible to feel anything but loathing for the man. He did that. Not me or my politics.

Anonymous
Guest
Anonymous

Agree. I looked at news of the protests and thought that it would be awful if Trump brought about regime change in Iran, before realizing how wrong that is. Were these protests to lead to regime change, that would be democracy and the people of Iran doing it, not Trump.